Acrylic Vs Tempera Paint: Get The Key Differences!

Randy Charles
Randy Charles
Professional Painter

Hi, I’m Randy Charles, the creator and chief editor of this site Paintcentric. I’m a businessman now by profession, but I used to work as...Read more

If you ever got yourself into painting and arts, you might have heard of the two most popular types of watercolors dominating the artistic world – acrylics, and tempera. Even though they are highly sought out paints by many professional painters, they are significantly different from each other in many aspects.

In the battle of acrylic vs tempera paint, the primary difference between both paints can be narrowed down to their respective ingredients’ involvement. Altogether, acrylic is a water-based, pigmented liquid paint that is emulsified with a synthetic polymer, while tempera is made of water-based, pigmented, egg-yolk-based paint.

And this article will show you the key differences between acrylic and tempera Paint: Get The Main Differences from their materials, consistency, price, and so on.

Acrylic Vs Tempera Paint: Side-By-Side Comparison Chart

In case you are in a hurry, here is a nifty table showing the main differences between these two paints. But, we suggest reading the entire article to have a broad idea of their differences.

Factors Tempera Paint Acrylic Paint
Base Water Acrylic polymer
Price Moderately-Low High
Dry Time 5 to 10 minutes 30 minutes or less
VOC Levels None to Little Reasonable
Cleaning After Easy (Water and Soap Only) Difficult (Paint-thinner needed)
Range Excellent Average
Elasticity Great Great
Durability Average Great
Resistance to Marking Great Great
Mold Resistance Average High
Useable Surfaces Paper, cardboard, cloth, wood, canvas Metal, masonry, plastic, wood

Acrylic Paint

This form of paint is described as fast-drying paint composed from pigments dispersed in an acrylic polymer emulsion. Paints made of acrylic are water-soluble, but they turn water-resistant once dry.

Acrylic Paint

Based on how much paint is diluted with water or altered with media, gels, or even pastes. Final acrylic painting may resemble gouache, watercolor, or oil painting or exhibit unique characteristics that are not achievable in other media. You can also try to mix acrylic and oil paint if you don’t want to dissolve water-based paints.

Acrylic paint is most typically used to paint canvases, but it can also be used to paint metal, wood, glass, plastic, and even glass.

Acrylic paint can be purchased at any art supply shop or on the internet.

Benefits
  • fast drying time
  • Available in a variety of vibrant colors
  • versatile array of implementations
  • The effects are permanent, making it ideal if you’re looking for durability
Drawbacks
  • can contain toxic chemicals
  • relatively costly
  • If you make a mistake, you can’t correct it as the paint is permanent
  • can get very messy

Tempera Paint

This paint is a kind of composition of color pigments and a binder (like glue or egg yolk) as well as water. It’s created by mixing the pigments with the binder and then adding water to form the paste.

Tempera Paint

Tempera paint can be used in classroom projects as well as craft projects, props for theater posters, art projects, color mixing activities, painting windows, and much more.

It’s best suited for porous surfaces like poster board, paper, and cardboard.

Benefits
  • water-based
  • simple to clean
  • easy to paint over or take off
  • nontoxic
  • offers a fast-drying period
  • ideal for projects that require a paper
  • extensive range of coloring
  • free of allergens
  • less expensive than acrylic paint
Drawbacks
  • Don’t last forever.
  • Not suitable for all surfaces
  • Layers of denser material may crack during drying
  • Remains water-soluble even in dry conditions
  • Disappears over time

What Is The Differences Between Acrylic Paint And Tempera Paint

There are some obvious distinctions between tempera and acrylic paint since they perform differently due to compositional contrasts. Let’s see how they differ from each other:

Acrylic Vs Tempera Paint - Get The Main Difference

Pigment

The significant distinction between tempera and acrylic pigment is their ingredients.

Tempera is made up of egg yolks and eggs and pigments; in contrast, acrylic pigment is made of chemical compounds which are synthesized from polymers.

That results in tempera paints becoming purer in comparison to acrylic. Because tempera is made of natural ingredients and acrylic is made up of plasticizers, synthetics, thickeners, and solvents.

Lightfastness

Lightfastness is the resistance of a pigment, dye, or other colorants to fading due to light exposure.  Water-based paints such as tempera  and acrylic  paint have variable lightfastness ratings.

Tempera is far less light-resistant than acrylic paint. Thus, most tempera colors and vibrancy will fade within a short span of time when exposed to sunlight. On the other hand, the acrylic paint’s pigment is lighter, which means it will maintain the original hue for a longer duration.

Permanence

Even though both tempera together with acrylic paints belong to a water-based category, they aren’t water-soluble. Tempera colors are water-soluble, meaning they are soluble even after being dried up, making them incredibly simple to wash off with water and soap.

In hindsight, for acrylic paints, the same can’t be said as they aren’t soluble, which means after drying up, they will be there permanently, possibly for years, if left sealed.

Consistency

Tempera has a creamy consistency corresponding to other paints, while acrylic is either a thin or thick matte or glossy finish, transparent or opaque, based on the type of material mixed with it.

Dried Appearance

When dried, Acrylic is visually flat, whereas, Tempera is dazzlingly shiny due to the fact that it is composed of egg yolks.

Blending Ability

Both types of paint excel in terms of blending abilities—both tempera and acrylic mix colors beautifully.

Presence Of Toxins

Tempera and acrylic are two different types of paints with different media. Acrylics are manufactured from a variety of chemical solvents, whereas tempera is made from egg yolk pigment that is dissolved in water.

Acrylics are Environmentally friendly, but they do have some toxins in them. However, tempera does not have any toxins in it and is considered more environmentally friendly, but it takes longer to dry compared to acrylic.

Color

Tempera paint usually produces more vibrant colors than acrylics, thanks to the shininess coming from the egg yolk pigment.

Viscosity

Acrylics are denser than tempera paints, which makes them harder to use. However, if you’re just beginning to learn about painting, tempera paints could be the better option since it’s less difficult to control.

Price

Pricewise tempera is more affordable than acrylic paint as the variety of complex chemicals needed to make acrylic paint highly supersede that of tempera.

However, you can find cheaper acrylic paints in stores based on their brand value and pigment count.

Materials

Acrylic together with tempera paints can be used on a plethora of materials due to their versatile medium. This paint is ideal for use on the following materials: Paper, Ceramic, Wood, Metal, Fabric, Canvas, and Plastic.

On the other hand, Paper, Newspaper print, Finger painting, Poster boards, Paper-mache, Canvas, Masonite boards, Cardboard, and Sponge painting are just a few of the materials that Tempera paint works well with.

Can You Mix Tempera And Acrylic Paint Together?

The answer is simple: no. Since tempera is a paint that is made up of pigments derived from natural sources.

When these two types of paints are mixed together, the results can be unpredictable and often inconsistent. This is partly due to the fact that acrylics offer a natural dry glossy finish.

Can You Mix Tempera And Acrylic Paint

However, tempera’s texture is almost watercolor-like, which has faded over time.  Because of that reason, painters favor acrylic for costly professional projects, whereas tempera is ideal for less expensive projects.

Can You Use Tempera Paint Like Acrylic?

It is possible to use tempera paint like acrylic, but it will not have the same qualities as acrylic. This paint has a straightforward formula that can be applied in many different ways.

Tempera paint, however, is a more complicated formula, and it should be applied with specific techniques.  For example, if we use tempera on canvas which is ideal for oil and acrylic because of their thickness, the result will be the paint dripping all over the floor.

The reason is that tempera’s not thick enough to hold the mixture to a single point. This causes the components to break within.

How To Make Tempera Paint Into Acrylic?

Here is the step-by-step guide on how to convert an acrylic paint into a tempera in your own home.

Necessary Equipment

  • A mixing container made of plastic.
  • A base made of acrylic.
  • Solution (water or alcohol similar to rubbing alcohol).
  • Acrylic retarder.
  • Wooden chopstick.
  • Dry pigment.
  • Painting spatula.

Step 1: Adequately grind the dry pigment with a painting spatula.

Step 2: Note and register the quantities of an acrylic base and pigment for a good consistency.

Step 3: Add the colorant into the base of acrylic of the container made of plastic and blend them thoroughly using a wooden chopstick till they are evenly distributed.

Step 4: Blend the solutions with an acrylic base that has been pigmented comprehensively.

Step 5: Mix in an acrylic retarder to illustrate how the acrylic paint dries.

Step 6: Install liquid paint and a regular glue mix container made from plastic and a wood chopstick in one place.

Step 7: Mix equal amounts of the paint in liquid form as well as the glue into the mixing container made of plastic.

Step 8: Combine the color and glue well using a wooden chopstick, and your acrylic paint will be ready in a few minutes.

Step 9: Stay sharp as, unlike your previous water-based tempera paint, this acrylic paint can stick to any surface for a prolonged time.

Step 10: Enjoy painting with your new dynamic acrylic paint.

Acrylic Or Tempera Paint: Which One Is the Right Choice For You?

Tempera is made of pigmented, egg-yolk-based paint and is the oldest type of paint. It dries quickly and covers a vast area with light, vibrant colors.  On the other hand, acrylic pigments are made of plasticizers and solvents, which make it go on smoother but can be more challenging to clean up.

Acrylic Or Tempera Paint - Which One Is The Right Choice For You

When choosing between tempera or acrylic painting, it’s essential to consider your personal preferences.  For example, some people find that tempera colors are easier to work with because they are more fluid; others prefer the smoothness of acrylics.  Ultimately, the best choice for you will depend on what you’re most comfortable working with.

Conclusion

To conclude, in the acrylic vs. tempera Paint comparison, we’ve learned a few things that put tempera paint and acrylic paint on opposite ends of the spectrum in terms of price and lightfastness, pigments materials, and so on.

Moreover, acrylic, as well as tempera paints, offer different benefits and drawbacks. For example, acrylic is a more durable paint but can be less flexible than tempera. However, tempera can be more flexible but is less stable.

Both paints can produce high-quality results, so it really comes down to personal preference and what you’re looking for in paint.

Randy Charles
Randy CharlesProfessional Painter

Hi, I’m Randy Charles, the creator and chief editor of this site Paintcentric. I’m a businessman now by profession, but I used to work as a painter earlier in my professional career. There is simply nothing about painting that I didn’t do as a painter. From painting a fridge to a multi-storied building, I left nothing. I retired from my painting job in the mid of 2018 due to back arthritis problems.

More Posts

Leave a Comment