Sherwin Williams Super Paint Vs Dunn Edwards Evershield: Which One Is Better?

Randy Charles
Professional Painter

Randy Charles is the owner of PaintCentric.com, a website dedicated to providing information, tips, tricks, and news about all things paint. With over 10 years...Read more

Choosing the right paint for your home is often a daunting task, with a variety of brands offering seemingly similar products. Trust me; I’ve been there too, spending hours comparing different paints like Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield.

After thoroughly researching these premium brands, this blog post will break down their key features, pros & cons to help simplify your decision-making process. Let’s dive into it!

Overview of Sherwin Williams Super Paint

Sherwin Williams Super Paint is a premium paint brand known for its high quality and durability.

Is Sherwin Williams’ Paints High-Quality Paint

Key Features of Sherwin Williams Super Paint

Sherwin Williams Super Paint boasts numerous features that set it above many other paint brands on the market. They include:

  • Impressive Fade Resistance: The top-notch quality of Sherwin Williams Super Paint guarantees a long-lasting hue that doesn’t fade quickly. This feature is a standout as compared to other paint brands, including Dunn-Edwards Evershield.
  • Enhanced Durability: It’s designed to withstand the test of time, making it ideal for both interior and exterior use.
  • Good Coverage Area: With just one gallon of this paint, you can comfortably cover an area between 300 to 400 square feet.
  • Quick Drying Time: Sherwin Williams Super Paint dries to the touch in an hour or less and is ready for a new coat within 3 to 4 hours.
  • Moderate VOC Levels: Depending on your chosen color, Super Paint offers zero to moderate Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs), making it more environmentally friendly than some alternatives.
  • Variety of Finish Options: Sherwin Williams Super Paint comes in various finishes, such as flat, satin, and gloss, giving you the flexibility to choose the best finish for your project.
Sherwin Williams Super Paint Quality Levels

Pros & Cons of Sherwin Williams Super Paint

Sherwin Williams Super Paint offers many benefits and a few drawbacks which we’re going to dive into here.

ProsCons
Provides better fade resistance, guaranteeing a long-lasting finish that remains vibrant over time.Is more expensive compared to other brands like Dunn-Edwards, which might not be ideal for those on a tight budget.
Has a slightly thick consistency which ensures a smooth and even application.The thick consistency might require more effort while applying, especially for those not familiar with painting.
Boasts high durability, ensuring that the paint can withstand harsh conditions without chipping or peeling.Despite its high durability, the paint could still show signs of wear and tear over time, especially in high-traffic areas.
Offers good coverage, with one gallon covering 300-400 sq. ft., reducing the need for multiple coats.Even though it provides a good coverage, in some cases, more than one coat might still be necessary for a seamless finish.
Dries to the touch in a reasonable amount of time, allowing for quicker project completion.Although it dries quickly, it’s important not to touch or disturb the paint while it’s drying to avoid any imperfections.
Is relatively easy to clean and can withstand light scrubbing, making it a great choice for families or those with pets.Despite its cleanability, harsh chemicals or rough scrubbing can damage the finish.
Offers a larger color selection compared to other brands, giving consumers a wide range of options to choose from.The overwhelming color options might make the selection process longer for those who are indecisive.

Overview of Dunn Edwards Evershield

Dunn Edwards Evershield is a premium exterior paint known for its durability and weather resistance. It offers excellent protection against the elements, including UV rays, ensuring long-lasting color and finish.

The paint has a slightly thick consistency, making it easy to apply and providing good coverage with one or two coats. Additionally, Dunn Edwards Evershield comes in a wide variety of colors and finishes, allowing homeowners to find the perfect option for their exterior projects.

Durability Of  Dunn Edwards Evershield

Key Features of Dunn Edwards Evershield

Dunn Edwards Evershield is a high-quality paint that stands out for its unique features tailored to meet the needs of both DIY homeowners and professional painters.

  1. Versatility: This paint is designed for both interior and exterior surfaces, providing flexibility in home projects.
  2. High Durability: Known for its long-lasting finish, the Evershield retains its look over time, minimizing the need for frequent touch ups or repaints.
  3. Fade Resistance: The product offers superior color retention properties which help it to resist fading even under harsh weather conditions or high sun exposure.
  4. Affordability: Evershield comes at a more budget-friendly price compared to some other premium paints on the market.
  5. VOC Levels: This line of paint has zero to moderate VOC levels, making it an environmentally friendly choice in painting projects.
  6. Good Coverage Area: One gallon of this paint can cover 350-400 sq ft., reducing the amount of paint needed for larger projects.
  7. Quick Drying Time: It dries to the touch in 30-60 minutes and is ready for an additional coat after 2-4 hours, allowing rapid progress in your painting project.
  8. Easy Application: It goes on smoothly and evenly, simplifying the application process whether you choose to roll, brush or spray it on.
Dunn Edwards Evershield Overview

Pros & Cons of Dunn Edwards Evershield

Dunn Edwards Evershield is a reliable choice for many homeowners and professionals due to its high-quality finish and cost-effectiveness. However, like any other product, it has its strengths and weaknesses. The following is a breakdown of its pros and cons which might assist you to make a more informed decision:

ProsCons
Offers a wide variety of colors and finishes to cater to different preferences.Though cost-effective, Dunn Edwards is still considered a premium brand, which may not fit into tighter budgets.
Covers approximately 350-400 sq. ft. per gallon, providing good coverage.Its durability, although commendable, may not match that of some other premium brands.
Easy to apply, dries to touch in 30-60 minutes, and ready for a second coat in 2-4 hours.Dunn Edwards has a smaller consumer product line compared to some of its competitors.
Known for its good quality with VOC levels ranging from zero to moderate.While it’s slightly thick consistency is preferred by some, others might find it less easy to work with compared to thinner alternatives.

Comparison Between Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield

Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield offer a variety of product lines, with similar texture and consistency, durability, fade resistance, VOC levels, ease of application and coverage.

They also have comparable drying time and cleaning properties. However, Sherwin Williams stands out with its larger color selection and industry-leading color-match technology.

Sherwin Williams Super Paint Vs Dunn Edwards Evershield

Variety of Product Line

Both Sherwin Williams and Dunn Edwards offer a wide range of product lines to cater to different painting needs. Sherwin Williams has an extensive consumer product line, including their popular Super Paint and Duration Home options, which are designed for both interior and exterior use.

On the other hand, Dunn Edwards offers a variety of paints such as Aristoshield, Everest, Exquisite, Spartawall, Spartazero, and Suprema that cater to specific requirements. With various colors and finishes available in their respective product lines, both brands provide ample options for homeowners looking to achieve their desired look.

Texture and Consistency

Both Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield offer paints with a slightly thick consistency, making them easy to apply. The texture is smooth and allows for even coverage, ensuring a professional-looking finish.

Whether you choose Sherwin Williams or Dunn Edwards, you can expect a paint that spreads smoothly and evenly on various surfaces. With their high-end quality, both paints provide excellent adhesion and hide imperfections effortlessly.

So, whether you’re repainting your interior walls or giving your home’s exterior a fresh coat of paint, both Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield will deliver an exceptional texture and consistency that will make your project look flawless.

Durability and Fade Resistance

In terms of durability and fade resistance, both Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield offer impressive performance. These paints are designed to withstand the test of time and maintain their vibrant colors even when exposed to harsh weather conditions.

Also Read: Best Dunn Edwards Exterior Paint: Top Choices for 2023

Sherwin Williams Super Paint is known for its exceptional fade resistance, ensuring that your paint job stays looking fresh for longer periods of time. On the other hand, Dunn Edwards Evershield also provides excellent durability, making it a reliable choice for high-traffic areas or exterior surfaces that are prone to wear and tear.

With these paints, you can have peace of mind knowing that your investment will remain intact, as they are formulated to protect against fading and discoloration caused by UV rays and other environmental factors.

Quality and VOC Levels

When it comes to the quality and VOC levels of Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield, both paints offer excellent durability and coverage. They are formulated to provide long-lasting protection for your surfaces.

In terms of VOC (volatile organic compound) levels, both brands have options that range from zero VOC to moderate VOC levels, making them safer for indoor use and less odorous compared to traditional high-VOC paints.

This means you can confidently choose either Sherwin Williams or Dunn Edwards knowing that you are selecting a paint with low toxicity and environmental impact.

Ease of Application and Coverage

Applying paint can be a hassle, especially if the product doesn’t spread easily or requires multiple coats. When it comes to ease of application and coverage, both Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint and Dunn Edwards Evershield offer great performance.

Both paints have a smooth consistency that glides effortlessly onto surfaces, making them user-friendly for both DIYers and professional painters alike. They also provide excellent coverage with just one to two coats, ensuring you get the job done efficiently.

Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint covers 300-400 sq. ft. per gallon, while Dunn Edwards Evershield covers 350-400 sq. ft., so you won’t need to worry about running out of paint too quickly during your project.

Drying Time and Cleaning

When it comes to drying time and cleaning, both Dunn-Edwards Evershield and Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint offer quick dry times and easy cleaning. Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint typically dries to the touch in around 1 hour, while Dunn-Edwards Evershield dries in just 30-60 minutes.

This means you can move on to another coat or continue with your project sooner. Both paints are ready for a new coat within a few hours, with Dunn-Edwards Evershield requiring 2-4 hours of wait time and Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint needing 3-4 hours.

Once fully dry within 24-48 hours, both paints provide a durable surface that is easy to clean. They can withstand light scrubbing without losing their luster or color integrity, making them ideal for high traffic areas or spaces prone to dirt and stains.

Price

In terms of price, there is a noticeable difference between Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield. Sherwin Williams paints are generally more expensive than Dunn Edwards paints, which can be a significant factor to consider when budgeting for your project.

However, it’s important to note that the cost-effectiveness of Dunn Edwards paints may lead to substantial savings in the long run. So if affordability is a priority for you, Dunn Edwards might be the better choice.

It’s always crucial to weigh the quality and features against the price when making your decision on which paint brand to go with.

Need for Primer with Sherwin Williams and Dunn Edwards Paints

When it comes to painting, the need for primer can vary depending on the brand and type of paint you choose. Sherwin-Williams offers paints with built-in primers, making a separate primer unnecessary.

This can save you time and money during your painting project. On the other hand, Dunn-Edwards recommends using a primer before painting with their paints as they typically do not come with built-in primers.

While using a separate primer adds an extra step to the process, it can help improve adhesion and ensure an even finish. It’s important to follow the manufacturer’s recommendations to achieve the best results with your chosen paint brand.

Where to Purchase Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield

If you’re interested in purchasing Sherwin Williams Super Paint or Dunn Edwards Evershield, here are some options to consider:

  • Sherwin Williams Super Paint can be purchased directly from Sherwin Williams stores, either in – person or online.
  • You can also find Sherwin Williams Super Paint at select home improvement stores like Lowe’s and independent paint retailers.
  • Dunn Edwards Evershield is available for purchase at Dunn Edwards paint stores, as well as online on their official website.
  • You might also find Dunn Edwards Evershield at certain independent paint retailers or specialty stores that carry Dunn Edwards products.

Alternatives to Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield

As an experienced SEO and high-end copywriter, I can assure you that the following paragraphs will be concise, engaging, and informative.

When considering alternatives to Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield, there are several other paint brands on the market that offer high-quality options for your painting needs.

One popular alternative is Benjamin Moore, known for their wide range of colors and excellent durability. Their paints also provide good coverage with minimal coats required.

Behr is another brand worth considering as an alternative. They offer a variety of interior and exterior paints that are known for their affordability without sacrificing quality. Behr paints have good fade resistance and are easy to apply with a smooth consistency.

For those looking for budget-friendly options, Valspar is a great alternative to consider. They offer a range of interior and exterior paints at lower price points while still maintaining decent durability and coverage.

Glidden is another reliable choice when it comes to finding alternatives to Sherwin Williams Super Paint or Dunn Edwards Evershield. Their paints provide good value for money with decent fade resistance and ease of application.

It’s important to note that while these alternatives may not have all the exact same features as Sherwin Williams or Dunn Edwards, they do offer comparable quality at various price ranges to suit different budgets.

Ultimately, the right paint brand will depend on your specific needs and preferences.

Conclusion: Which Paint Is Better, Sherwin Williams Super Paint or Dunn Edwards Evershield?

In conclusion, when it comes to Sherwin Williams Super Paint vs Dunn Edwards Evershield, both paints offer great durability and quality. However, Sherwin Williams takes the lead with its superior fade resistance and industry-leading color-match technology.

While Dunn Edwards is more budget-friendly, Sherwin Williams provides a wider variety of options and overall better performance. Ultimately, the choice between the two will depend on your specific needs and preferences for your painting project.

FAQs

1. What are the differences between Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield?

Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield are both high-quality paints, but they differ in terms of their formulation, coverage, durability, and color options. It’s important to consider your specific painting needs before deciding which one is better for your project.

2. Which paint offers better coverage and durability?

Both Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield offer excellent coverage and durability, but the choice depends on factors such as surface type, location (interior or exterior), exposure to weather elements, and level of foot traffic. Consulting with a professional painter or representative from each brand can help you determine which option best suits your specific needs.

3. Are there any notable differences in color options between these two paints?

Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield both offer a wide range of colors to choose from. However, it’s recommended to visit their respective websites or stores to explore their color palettes firsthand as they may have unique shades that appeal more to your desired aesthetic.

4. Can I use either paint brand interchangeably without compromising quality?

While both Sherwin Williams Super Paint and Dunn Edwards Evershield are reputable brands known for quality paints, it’s generally not recommended to interchange them without considering factors such as compatibility with existing coatings or primers used on surfaces you intend to paint. To ensure optimal results for your project, it’s advisable to consult with professionals who can provide guidance based on your specific requirements.

Randy CharlesProfessional Painter

Randy Charles is the owner of PaintCentric.com, a website dedicated to providing information, tips, tricks, and news about all things paint. With over 10 years of experience in the painting industry, Randy has become an expert in the field and is passionate about helping others learn more about painting. He has written numerous articles on the subject and is committed to providing accurate and up-to-date information to his readers.

Leave a Comment

five × 5 =